It's not a huge deal for me now that I realize it's seperated youtube videos and spotify streams. Those for me are fine on seperate channels, though maybe some artists would want them together or linked.
Something I think is more important is for songs streamed on streaming services to auto select the official stream video (sometimes marked with "-topic" after the artists name and sometimes on their official channel) that most music on streaming will generate on youtube. For me it did automatically but for bigger artists there are lots of fan made videos and sometimes AI generated videos. I suspect this steals some of the revenue from the artists (for bigger artists I personally don't care but for middle sized or smaller artists, I would not like if that were the case) but also it creates a completely different mood that doesn't always match the song. I've also seen in my recent snap of Air's song that one user was region blocked from this fan generated video.
ALSO, my snaps don't show up on the song page of scrobble!! Checked the songs again and my comment is gone!
And if there's a way to see all my scrobble snaps on my scrobble profile that would be really really helpful!
And the ability to rate albums as a snap instead of just leaving comments on songs would be nice!
Yeah, we've had trouble fetching the official/proper youtube songs when they're initially scrobbled through another platform. We do plan on allowing scrobblers to edit the links if they find it fetched the wrong one so it'll depend a lot on community input eventually and probably evolve into something wikipedia like where enough users need to vote in what they deem to be the correct one and it'll take the option of the majority.
Are you actually scrobbling the songs with the extension? That may be part of the issue but I'll look deeper into your reports here in a bit.
The wiki thing is a good idea although i imagine defualting to the "topic" account songs will probably save a lot of work once you figure it out.
i am using the extension on chrome with spotify.
Right now when I click the album page, I see a place for "reviews" but I don't see any Comments/short takes on the album, the artist or the song pages. Nor anywhere on my profile. It's like after I snap, the only place they exist is snappie. My listens are all being processed fine
Ah now I get it, thanks will look into getting that viewed in the right places!
Why do some songs or videos only log as listened to but don't create pages? So far it's happened with all the videos I watch on youtube. I can't make comments on them because they don't have pages but they show up when I search for them, I just can't click, there's no link
Spent a lot of time on this today + some other finds along the way, do you feel like this is better?
there's always this section for specific songs as well in /music:
Fantastic! I hope it doesn’t phase them out as more come in and I can navigate previous ones too but it looks really nice and is what I was hoping for!
Have you tried leaving comments on the /music section? I suppose we could create pages for them as well, let me check
Many of these aren’t the full song, maybe that’s why they don’t register? Some are live recordings without any song on streaming too