While picking Smallsteps up from a birthday party, I was talking to one of the other parents as we waited for them to finish sticking plastic diamonds onto something to make a bookmark of some kind. It was all very glittery. However, our discussion was about his parents and older people in general, where there are those who stay active and those who do nothing after retirement. I have always found it interesting that people work for most of their life with the goal of getting out of work and doing nothing. Why not just do nothing from the start?

But I think it is unfortunate that we have created a world where even highly educated people are required to do meaningless work throughout their life that given the opportunity, they would escape. I think that if we focused on solving real problems we face as a species, there would be an abundance of meaningful work that people would be happy to add value to for as long as they can - like the scientists or artists of old who worked until they couldn't work anymore.
But I also think that we should go back as much as possible to the tribal idea of community where everyone adds value in the ways they can, and no one is really able to do nothing. When the elders couldn't do the hard labour tasks anymore, they looked after the younger generations, teaching them, passing on experience and skills. It meant that everyone was not only contributing, everyone was relevant.
A lot of older people are irrelevant today because many have chosen to limit their contributions under the assumption that whatever they did in the past was enough. I don't think that is how life works. It is like eating a big meal and saying, that will do me for the rest of life. What this means is that their relevancy is limited mostly to what they can contribute economically through consumption and inheritance, because the skills and experience they have is lost because they are no longer willing to share it with the younger generations, because many are no longer willing to raise grandkids.
It used to take a village, now it takes a screen.
But it is a poor substitute for the experience of elders. And, there are lessons to be learned in caring for elders too, both as the children of the elderly looking after them in old age, and as the grandchildren who learn a lot of skills navigating the conditions of the elderly. The exposure of the tribe meant from life to death, everyone was part of the experience through all of the stages, whereas now it is kind of compartmentalised, where there are large periods of relatively no contact. Of course, this is culturally dependent, but I suspect that even the strong community and family cultures, are drifting further apart today.
Of course, one of the factors that has changed heavily in many regions of the world is that families no longer live in multigenerational homes together. In the past, there might be four generations living under the one roof, but now because of the desire for independence, that doesn't happen very often. This has a big effect on the dynamics of the family, but also the potential of the family, where the entire burden is on parents to raise their kids, with many not getting much family support at all.
Helping each other put has become a major inconvenience, whereas before it was more of a privilege to remain an important, relevant part of the family. Many want that family unit closeness of course, but when it comes to doing the required things to build it, people have little stamina. And this has a knock-on effect into so many social dysfunctions today, and likely a partial reason for such a drop in birth rates also. Members of communities support each other, but if people are only there to get support and are unwilling to provide support, the community is unsustainable.
I wish that we all had jobs we wouldn't want to retire from, because that would mean they are meaningful and we feel valued in what we do. That would likely require the jobs to focus primarily on creating wellbeing within society, including improving the conditions that support it, like a healthy environment. But the fact is, even when we are in those kinds of roles, our capabilities change, but that doesn't mean we can't add value. Yet, many will choose the road of valueless living, lamenting why conditions are so bad, the young so terrible, and society is falling apart.
A parent plays a role in a child's life, whether they are good, bad, present or absent.
Cultural structures are built off our behaviours, not our ideals.
That means that we paly a part in both the good and the bad parts and if we want to increase the good, decrease the bad, and bring in better actions - we have to change our behaviours. We can't rest on our laurels and assume that we are entitled to remain relevant in society, when we are no longer actively part of it. We can't expect people to respect us, when they have had so little interaction with us, or people like us. They say "respect your elders" but being an elder wasn't just based on age, it was on the value of the experience that the person shared with the tribe, the community.
Culture is always changing.
Any idea where it is improving?
Taraz
[ Gen1: Hive ]
Be part of the Hive discussion.
- Comment on the topics of the article, and add your perspectives and experiences.
- Read and discuss with others who comment and build your personal network
- Engage well with me and others and put in effort
And you may be rewarded.
I have no silver bullets. As the economy crumbles, we see two forces: people who travel away to find opportunity, and those who consolidate their families to save money. Both have merits and drawbacks, including the strength and virtue (or absence thereof) in older generations.
Me either. But something will change and the change at the moment is getting worse.
I agree with your view on meaningful work and the importance of keeping older people actively connected, so that their wisdom is not lost. But…
However, I think it’s also worth pointing out that —whether we like it or not, and even if we have the best and most rewarding job in the world— the cycle of life eventually catches up with us. Ageing naturally brings with it fatigue and a decline in our abilities. You know that there comes a time when we must step aside and make way for the younger generations.
We must learn to accept this cycle and live each stage of life to the full, just as it is, adapting our role with grace rather than fighting against nature.
Many blessings to you, and a special hello to little Smallsteps!
Yes, aging does catch up with us, but considering that people are living about 50 years longer now than in tribal life, it is pretty sad that we are not using the extra time as a community.
Maybe the real lesson is that aging is a privilege, not a penalty, if we still get to teach
I don't think retirement should mean withdrawing from life altogether. Everyone should have plans for life after retirement; otherwise, they may end up feeling that something is missing. For example, I am planning to live by the sea and travel as much as I can. 😉
I find that experience doesn't lose its value with age, sometimes it becomes even more meaningful
Older generations have something that cannot simply be learned from books or screens: the knowledge gained through living
Perhaps the real problem isn't retirement itself, but the idea that our contribution to life should eventually come to an end.
I have a job that I actually really like and don't really want to retire from. But it pays about half of what this same job pays in the private sector...
This problem also appears due to the way we live. In the past, people was living in small villages, where everyone knew each other and respected the knowledge of the old experienced ones. Everything was more physical and you needed way many more physical skills to survive.
Now, people living in big cities do not know even who are their neighbors. Physical needs once we used cover local known experts, are now covered by contracting services from companies and workers you do not know and have no personal relationship. People do not feel the need to learn them as they can just pay for the service, but we are more and more dependent as the knowledge is lost we become more and more ignorant and the sense of community is disapearing.
One of the things I am experiencing since I started the farm project in Portugal is this way of living. There is way more contact with neighbors as many times you need help from others. You learn from them as most of the time you get involved in the job, helping hem, and you have a bigger respect for their knowledge as you get to know them personally. That knowledge can be passed between generations. The feeling of community is way bigger.
It is interesting to see how this physical professions are the ones which are becoming way more valuable with the explosion of AI.
Maybe real development has nothing to do with independence, but rather with the recognition of how much we really depend on each other.
Each generation has something to offer, and a community that ceases to share knowledge, care for each other, and build meaningful relationships is gradually losing its human nature.
We need each other not only to survive, but also to find meaning in life.
I think it doesn't help that kids don't respect the wisdom of elders either. It's less of something they take to heart and more like something they just smile and nod to try and humor you. My nieces and nephews are pretty great (better than most in my opinion), but I still know there is a point where they probably value something they heard on TikTok more than some random wisdom I am dropping on them.