To start off, I would like to say that I highly appreciate the team and what they have done so far actually creating a really fun game (at least at higher levels) and I'm looking forward to everything that is yet to come.
That being said, it can't be denied that attracting new players and selling them on the game has been a major issue. Even though Spliterlands is the most successful Crypto Game out there, having 6000 active daily players (with half of them probably being bots) is a complete joke for a game like this in the real gaming world for a game that is over 2 years old.
Sure, the chart with the number of players (Link) has gone up, but it's nowhere near the potential this game should have at the moment and things don't seem to be improving.
Why Onboarding New Players Is So Bad
I see 2 main reasons why new players would try out Splinterlans. The first one is the belief/hope they will be able to earn some money with it (99% of the cases right now). The second because there is buzz around it in the gaming world with coverage on actual gaming sites and some youtube/twitch influencers playing it (totally non-existing at the moment)
The team has pretty much nailed the sign-up procedure which is quick and easy and doesn't require any knowledge about blockchain whatsoever (big props for that). Once that is done, the real pain starts as the game requires way too much mental effort while it doesn't give any sense of rewards whatsoever. Looking at my own affiliates 60%+ of the ones that sign up don't get further than playing zero to 3 matches. The ones that do play more nearly all end up enjoying the game and based on my own numbers around ~70% continue to play the game (See Affiliate Numbers) which is awesome!
I do know the team is working on a tutorial to solve the issue of the game being too overwhelming at first but I fear that it will be way too complicated and lack any sense of rewards and progression especially with the new collection score. If I hear the devs talk in the Discord AMA I'm honestly losing faith.
"New players will be able to experience the game and will get a taste of what it's all about, they will start gradually winning some cards over time. Collection power, it's not a thing where they go OMG, I'm never going to get that far I'm going to give up. I mean hopefully, they will see it as a goal to work towards' ...
The way I personally see it it goes like this:
New players pay 10$ to get a not so fun initial experience (early levels in the game are simply less fun), they will see an instant paywall in the collection score system without experiencing any sense of progression and say fuck this game, worst pay2win ever!
Possible Solutions
1) Collection Score
I 100% agree that the game has been giving out (and still is giving out) way too many rewards and that they need to be cut back drastically. Having them linked to the collection power and how much players invested into the game is not a bad system in my view. The way it is implemented right now just completely goes against human psychology and simply reversing that could mostly fix this. Right now, all players aside from those in the top leagues with a collection of far above 1000$ totally feel screwed over as they see it as being put behind a paywall.
I have yet to see a solid argument on why it wouldn't be way better to:
LOWER ALL REWARDS AND GIVE BONUS REWARDS FOR PLAYERS WITH HIGHER COLLECTION SCORES
From a psychological point of view, this would feel way fairer to all players. Instead of being punished for not having enough cards they now get rewarded for investing more in the game. Everything else is pretty much exactly the same as it is right now.
2) New Player Sense of Progression
The game gives little to no sense of progression or rewards to new players at the moment or reasons to play at least 20+ games so new players get passed a certain point where they start to understand how everything works wanting more.
Objectives
- Play a Ranked Game
- Win a Ranked Game
- Enter a Tournament
- Play A total of 5 Matches
- Play A total of 10 Matches
- Play A total of 50 Matches
- Play A total of 100 Matches
- Complete the tutorial
- 2 days consecutive logins
- 3 days consecutive logins
- 5 days consecutive logins
- Buy a card on the market
- Join a Guild
- ...
Objective Completion Rewards
Many exclusive cards are being created and printed as an airdrop for players that bought packs. Why not create a card that is being given to new players that get the summoner's spellbook and complete a certain task like playing 100 games. The card itself can be a meme legendary card with the only real function to provide some initial collection power to new players to get them going in that regard. More possible rewards:
- DEC
- Potions
- Loot Chest
- Discount on 1st Pack purchase
- Cosmetic Items
- Exclusive New Player Card
- ...
REWARDS PSYCHOLOGY
I guess this is a statement that describes Splinterlands when it comes down to rewards compared to traditional games.
TRADITIONAL GAMES GIVE PLAYERS EMPTY REWARDS THAT FEEL REAL, SPLINTELANDS GIVES PLAYERS REAL REWARDS THAT FEEL EMPTY.
Whenever I ask friends about their season or daily quest rewards it almost always goes like, "A bunch of garbage and lost of useless potions". I feel the same even though I know better since I closely track the rewards the game gives me. (See my Monthly Earnings Report). When you consistently collect the rewards, it certainly all adds up. The occasional great reward you inevitably get just doesn't provide enough of a dopamine rush or sense of reward/progression right now.
Possible Solution
Remove Epic Cards / Legendary Cards / Golden Common Cards / Golden Rare-Epic-Legendary Cards / Untamed Packs / Dice Packs and replace them by specific tokens (or whatever). In order to unlock one of these specific card/pack rewards, you need to collect let's say 10 or more of these tokens (They can even increase the 'mining difficulty over time' in a pre-determined way.) Make a separate Rewards page full with progression meters that track how far along players are when it comes down to unlocking these more valuable rewards.
A system like this would give way more sense of progression as you see meters fill up closer to reaching the rewards each day giving a dopamine rush. Since there are multiple meters, there will always be some that are close to being completed which makes it hard for players to stop playing since they always are going to want to reach just one more.
A system like this would also make it easy to reduce the rewards cards that are given out without players experiencing it this and even increase the number of loot chests that are being rewarded.
The reality now is that reward cards are still going out way too fast even though it has been cut down already. You can follow how fast they are being printed Here.
The 2 latest new reward cards were released only last month (See Post). By now with 6000 Daily active Players/Bots, 16%+ of all cards are already in circulation which is a pace that is just way too fast! Just imagine the game having 25k+ players let alone 100k+ active players.
SIGN-UP PROMO OFFER
 |
 |
 |
Interesting points that you are raising here. Although personally I am pretty happy about the game and its status quo, I hope this will lead to some discussion.
Thanks for sharing! - @ashikstd
Fantastic one.
I hope this post will be so helpful to some peoples.
Nice thoughts and suggestions.
Cheers.
Wow I think the progress bars / tokens for the rare, epic... cards is a really good solution.
I don't really like the new ranking system but I already hated the reward & potion change before: I have hundreds of potions that I'm never gonna use because I don't buy that many packs. So it always feels so empty and useless when I open rewards and only get potions,
The token system reminds me of the League of Legends system. They too made it harder to earn the in-game currency to buy characters but they added some extra "shards" rewards that you could collect and use for skins or characters.
It was really hard to get enough of them for anything but just knowing you actually could use them in the future for something really nice, a nice skin or extra character, made you feel good about getting them and made collected them worthwile.
Thanks, I'm testing out the leaderboards this season but from what it looks like, those 'in the money' just have way higher collection values compared to the league they compete in. (like 2 Million+ collection score in the Silver league). I just hope they manage to lower rewards but make players feel like they are actually getting more which should be perfectly possible. I am looking forward to everything to come and it will be interesting to see how it all plays out. I still enjoy the game and think it feels way less repetitive than on would expect with all the different rules. lot of tweaking left to do though.
Yea, one thing that got better are the fights. They are harder now as I feel that there are less bots and you get to fight against players with better cards too.
I feel like diamond league is the hardest because a lot of people with stronger cards want to stay in there to get better rewards. I wonder however if they can do something to disincentive this "staying in a lower league for rewards".
Fixing the rewards will probably be hard. ATM I think that new players don't get enough rewards to motivate them and the biggest player get a lot. So this means that as a new player you grow slow and as a big player you grow fast. It makes sense to give more rewards to the top players but I feel like there should be some more balancing done to not create a "DEX wealth gap". 😂
You have very good points mentioned here. I agree with some and disagree with others but most of your advice will certainly help Splinterlands.
@tipu curate
Upvoted 👌 (Mana: 0/12)