Sort:  

I use Keychain. When you asked me that it got me thinking - what if my keys are different now? Lo-and-behold that's exactly the case. My keys are different.

I've been unable to change my recovery account because of this problem too, but even that has been fixed.

Funny to think that a question can also be an answer. Thanks for the help lol

Awesome, glad you have been able to solve it ;)