I was about to write this post these days. I had been noticing in my posts some random comments from new accounts that don't use their own photo. Comments that are meaningless or too generic. So when you look at the comments that these accounts made by POB they were always very similar, but changing a few words. I remember asking @amr008 about the script in cases like this. However, I didn't go too far in looking to see if these users were benefiting from comment gains. What bothered me most was that they were meaningless comments. And I also noticed that most of these comments were made based on the title you were writing and not the text. It became clearer when I looked at some cases when the titles were very different from the context of the subject made in the post.
I also decided to test in addition to answering everyone as I do, I asked a question questioning something about the comment I had spoken, so I could understand the point of view and at the same time test these accounts. To date none of them have responded to the continuation although they have continued to comment on new posts of mine and I kept trying to get a more concrete answer.
When @amr008's announcement came out about the withdrawal of delegations and projects I can't say if it was a coincidence or what, but the frequency of the same comments dropped a lot. I'm still going to analyze this rest of the month to be sure. But one thing is certain: I've never liked comments like that, made out of laziness or just forced to participate in something. When thinking about doing this, at least in my posts, don't do it, don't waste your time.
====================
Português
Com O Fim do Projeto do AMR008 os comentários serão agora mais reais?
Eu estava para escrever esse post por esses dias. Eu vinha notando em meus posts alguns comentários aleatórios de contas novas e que não usam foto própria. Comentários sem muito sentido ou genéricos demais. Então quando você olha os comentários que essas contas faziam pelo POB eram sempre muito parecido, mas mudando algumas palavras. Eu lembro de ter questionado o @amr008 sobre o script em casos assim. Porém, não fui afundo olhar para saber se esses usuários estavam se beneficiando com ganhos em comentários. O que me incomodava mais era o fato de serem comentários sem sentido. E percebi também que boa parte desses comentários eram feitos baseados no título que você escrevia e não do texto. Ficou mais claro quando olhei alguns casos quando os títulos eram bem diferentes do contexto do assunto feito no post.
Também resolvi testar além de responder todos como eu faço, eu fazia uma pergunta questionando algo sobre o comentário que havia falado, para eu entender o ponto de vista e ao mesmo tempo testar essas contas. Até hoje nenhuma delas respondeu a continuação embora elas terem continuado a comentar em posts novos meus e eu continuava tentando ter uma reposta mais concreta.
Quando o anúncio do @amr008 saiu sobre a retirada das delegações e dos projetos eu não sei dizer se foi uma coincidência ou quê, mas a frequência dos mesmos comentários caiu muito. Ainda vou analisar esse resto de mês para eu ter certeza. Mas uma coisa é certa: Eu nunca gostei de comentários assim, feitos na preguiça ou apenas forçado para participar de algo. Quando pensar em fazer assim, ao menos nos meus posts nem faça, nem perca tempo.
I very much doubt it was a coincidence. The comments will definitely decrease. The @amr008 project was amazing, but I think it was a positive point that it ended because there were a lot of people benefiting for pure interest in pobs and not genuinely interacting.
I have this same vision as yours.
The positive side is the end of these boring comments around here.
Hahhaaha i do noticed this as well, some times is just irritating , like why comment on someone post if you won't even bother to read the content?
I guess the few comments now will be real at least .
Yes! I agree.
I really love reading your comments that are real and true. And I hope this gets stronger and stronger!
I will definitely continue to learn and improve in all my activities here.
I totally agree with you on this one. A lot of people seem te be focussing on the quantity of comments, but it's more the quality of comments that counts.
I thought I had seen an initiative to reward the best comment of the day too. I think that's a better way of appreciating comments.
That's also how I do this on Noise.Cash. People that provide a useful, funny comment get an upvote.
I think I should do that over here more too.
It's a really interesting idea. This could be added to something within the POB curators as well to help.
Let's see what @scholaris thinks about this
;)
I like the idea. I do something similar in my curation. If the conversation flows, then I reward most of the comments. The more engaging the comment the higher the reward.
It is true! Now that you've talked about it I remember having seen it being done by you
Yeah. All my curation is manual now. It's pretty easy to do, but it takes a really long time.
Yes!
I also only do manuals
Eu também percebi isso, e acho que a frequência dos comentários (e principalmente a qualidade deles) irá mesmo diminuir.
Já tenho notado isso. Embora acredito que alguns "bots" estão com um pouco de delay para perceber que acabou xD
Wonderful
I like amr008 activity and statistics here
Esse cara aqui nem leu teu texto e nem deve tá ligado que o projeto acabou, pra fazer um comentário desses...
Era esse tipo de comentários que eu vinha me incomodando sempre hahaha
Eu tava quase fazendo um concurso pra quem achasse o comentário mais sem noção, kkk
mas como o projeto do amr acabou, acredito que esse tipo de comentário será cada vez mais raro
In a way, the engagement will be more organic. Shoot, I might throw random 100% upvotes on comments I like just to keep the magic going.
Exactly. Now we will have the real comments.
Since the days of WOTW having the criteria of engagement to win comments, even if more "real", they were only "forced" to be made. Nothing organic. After this was no longer valid, people stopped commenting.
I'm much more in favor of real interaction, the one we're having here today for example ;)
Noted
Olha esse também @aiuna hahaha
Commenting is a kind of conversation. @amr00 is a great project. I am sorry to hear that project halts now. However, as a community, commenting should continue though there is no reward system. I hope more curators will also leave some reward for ones who engage actively.
Yes, it must always continue. But in a real and more organic way!
Hahaha, I love the way you just poured out your mind on this post.😀
I too have noticed that since the profits for making a lot of comments seized, Comments have reduced a lot, Infact, My recent posts no longer have much comments like the way it had before.
One might begin to think it was because of the comment gains that was why comments were flooding in.
But like you said, Comments would be more real now.
Really! I'm also noticing that several people were noticing this and not just me. And that's great!
I really don't like forced comments.
Yeah, You ever heard the saying 'Everyone goes where there is benefits?' That's exactly how it goes.
Some people who just wanted the benefits were going to the comment box to get their rewards.😁