Part 8/11:
The Original Moana vs. The New Version: Stakeholders and Cultural Authenticity
Casting considerations further complicate the remake. Fans pointed out that the actress portraying young Moana in the teaser looks notably older than the character’s intended age, which is roughly 14. There’s skepticism about whether the casting truly reflects Polynesian cultural authenticity, especially considering Disney’s history of casting decisions.
Some believe the decision to stick closely to the original animation’s visual style signifies a fear of deviating from the source, potentially alienating fans. Others speculate that Disney is avoiding risks—recreating Moana almost identical to the original in hopes of appealing to those who cherish the animation while avoiding controversy.