Part 5/7:
The Controversy and Implications
Hamill’s account reveals that he envisioned Luke as a deeply troubled individual, haunted by personal tragedy. This contrasts sharply with the heroic image most fans cherished—highlighting the disconnect between his personal headcanon and the cinematic portrayal in the sequel trilogy.
He admits that his envisioned backstory wasn't meant to justify the film’s portrayal but serves as a way to understand the character's complex psychology. Yet, this dark fiction underscores how disconnected the modern interpretations are from the original hero he brought to life.