[WE-164] - The death dilemma

in Weekend Experiences7 months ago

I haven't written for a while (taking a small break for personal reasons) but good to be back writing this weekend. I picked this topic from this weekend engagement questions from @aglenkp entitled "The death dilemma". If I had to choose to execute someone to save my own skin, could I do it? Would I really kill someone else to save myself?

My immediate thought was I couldn't kill someone. However, then I thought about my wife, my kids, and my wider family. How would this be on everyone who depends on me so much in life?

I also wondered if I am just too chicken. If it really came down to it, would I just go against my beliefs and save myself at any cost?

However, I think I would then weigh up the other individuals to judge if I felt that they were worth more than me. It feels like such a dark and arrogant thought but I think we all do it all the time, we judge the worth of ourselves against those around us. Are we all equal?

It reminded me of the movie Worth which was about an attorney, on the back of the September 11th terrorist act, trying to work out how much different lives were worth as the US government calculated compensation for the victims. Lawyers do this the whole time, they calculate the worth of individuals.

The idea is that someone who is a CEO in a big organisation with an expensive lifestyle is "worth" more than an unemployed person living on welfare. One could argue that their loss has more of a financial impact and therefore their loss is worth more.

So when deciding if I take someone else out to save myself, does it depend on who the others are? If it is an old man who is in his latter years does it make his "worth" less than mine? What about a young man with his full life in front of him? His potential may be more than mine. What about a mother of a child? Does it sound sexist or just natural to have a different sensitivity to women in a way I may not have for other men?

So, I do think I would look around at the others. Judge their worth. If one of them is worth less than me. Perhaps I would save myself.


Image source: Pexels

Sort:  

Hi @awah,
Thank you for participating in the #teamuk curated tag. We have upvoted your quality content.
For more information visit our discord https://discord.gg/8CVx2Am

Looks like someone kidnapped you. Then offered you a duel. Before that he/she told you about his or her life to help you deciding about his/her worth! Then only you can compare the between you and the attacker!
This doesn't make sense. If someone want to hurt you, it's your every right to try your best to protect yourself. If it needs to kill someone to save your family or yourself, there is no problem I think.

Will a noble person come to kill you? Nope.

But here in this scenario, I am not killing the one who is threatening to kill me. I have to choose the person to kill as a way of saving myself. Pick someone innocent, or be killed myself.

An interesting though experiment. I think the truth is that we just don't know how we would act in the heat of the moment.
!ALIVE
!PIZZA
!WINE
!LOLZ
!BBH

@awah! Your Content Is Awesome so I just sent 1 $BBH (Bitcoin Backed Hive) to your account on behalf of @davidthompson57. (1/5)

@awah! You Are Alive so I just staked 0.1 $ALIVE to your account on behalf of @davidthompson57. (1/20)

The tip has been paid for by the We Are Alive Tribe through the earnings on @alive.chat, feel free to swing by our daily chat any time you want, plus you can win Hive Power and Alive Power delegations and Ecency Points in our chat every day.

I think you are right, i expect we would all behave a little unpredictably as the pressure of the moment would take away the ability to think rationally.

!wine
!BBH

@davidthompson57! Your Content Is Awesome so I just sent 1 $BBH (Bitcoin Backed Hive) to your account on behalf of @awah. (3/5)

PIZZA!

$PIZZA slices delivered:
@davidthompson57(1/15) tipped @awah