Como saber si tu canción es realmente buena[ESP-ENG]

in Music2 years ago

Bueno primero que todo, para que una canción sea buena, te tiene que gustar jajajaja


First of all, in order to a song to be good, it has to be good for you hahaha

Aquí no somos tan superficiales, o si??
We are not that shallow minded.. or are we??
Existen muchas cosas que pueden hacer realmente buena a una canción, lo primordial es que tu consideres que es buena, Tambien hay factores como el nivel de los arreglos musicales y su interpretación, el mensaje de la letra, la calidad de grabación...

Luego hay factores mas objetivos como las ventas, el numero de streams(digo objetivos porque son solo números y los números suelen ser objetivos jajaja)

Como puedes ver, yo se cuales son pero no se como ponerlo en practica porque mis canciones son malas🤣🤣

pero no vamos a hablar de todo lo que mencione antes porque es todo un enredo yo tengo una prueba de oro fácil que puedes hacerle a casi cualquier canción, para saber si es buena, para saber si es un temazo.

There are many things than can make a song really good, in first place, you need to think that song is good, also there is stuff like the musical arrangement, its performance, the meaning of the lyrics, the recording quality...

Then we have more objetive stuff like revenue, the streams, (I said objetive because these are only numbers and numbers use to be objetive hahaha)

As you can see, I know what these things are but i don't how how to use them because my songs are pretty bad🤣🤣

But today we are not gonna talk about all that stuff that I said because I have a golden test for you to prove any song worth in an easy way, then you would know if that song is really good


La prueba Acustica😲/The acoustic test

Es sencillo, para que tu tema sea bueno, debe poder ser tocado solamente con una guitarra o piano y una voz o instrumento líder, es decir, en version acústica con muy pocos elementos.

Si puede ser tocado así, y suena bien, ahi esta todo, no importa que tanta caña le metas después, tu canción es un temazo.

Keep it simple, if your song can be played by only guitar or piano and the vocal or lead instrument, then you have a great song I mean, you need to be able to play it on acoustic version with few elements.

If you play it that way and it sounds good, no matter how much stuff you put on that song after, you have a great song!


Si no me crees míralo/óyelo tu mismo en estos ejemplos:

you don't believe me? watch it/hear it yourself:


Dua lipa - New rules

Version original
Version acustica


Los mesoneros - Caiga la noche

Version original
Version acustica


Phil Collins - In the air tonight

Version original
Cover acústico


A este punto puedes estar pensando:

"¿Y que pasa con las canciones que no pueden ser tocadas de esta forma?"
Bueno eso necesariamente NO las hace malas canciones, hay muchísimas canciones que me encantan y definitivamente no pueden ser tocadas con 2 elementos, pero digamos que pueden estar sujetas a una pequeña desventaja.

Es decir, si esa canción no pasa el test, siempre vas a necesitar mas recursos para poder presentarla en vivo, eso podría ser una pequeña desventaja frente a alguien que simplemente trajo su guitarra y dio un performance inolvidable.

¿Que piensas de esta prueba? ¿Funcionaria siempre?

At this point you may think like "what if a song really cannot be played that way?"

Well, that is not necessarily a bad thing, I mean, there's a lot of songs that really cannot be played this way, it doesn't makes them bad songs, but they can have a tiny disadvantage.

I mean, if that song doesn't pass it, you'll always need more resources to performance live, that can be the tiny disadvantage in front someone who just brought his guitar to gave a remarkable performance

What do you think about this test? is it accurate?


Por ultimo te muestro una de mis canciones originales "far away life" sometida a este test, ¿que opinas? ¿paso la prueba?

At last, I would like to share with you, one of my original songs "far away life, submitted to this test, what do you think? It went through?

Sort:  

Congratulations @jotadiaz12! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You received more than 100 HP as payout for your posts and comments.
Your next payout target is 250 HP.
The unit is Hive Power equivalent because your rewards can be split into HP and HBD

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Check out the last post from @hivebuzz:

Hive Power Up Month - Feedback from Day 12