RE: Add Automatic Reports for the D-A-CH Support Bot

[syedumair]

Your contribution cannot be approved because it is not related to technical issues.

---

Need help? Write a ticket on https://support.utopian.io.
Chat with us on Discord.

[utopian-moderator]

Comments

[obvious]

Your contribution cannot be approved because it is not related to technical issues.

Well, all suggestions refer to the technical implementation and the resulting benefits for the community. It has no graphical and optical requirements. The rules also state:

Suggestions are minor features / enhancements to an Open Source project.

That is exactly what I proposed in my post.

Maybe you can ask the project manager (@jedigeiss) for his opinion on this?

Thanks for your time.

[syedumair]

Every minor feature requires technical implementation, however that does not mean we accept every suggestion.

[louis88]

Why does a proposal for an open source project need to have a technical background? It is much more about the fact that the Open Source project can be improved by suggestions so that it brings more advantages in the future.

[syedumair]

Suggestions may only relate to significant technical aspects of the project (rather than processes or organisational issues).

You can read utopian rules if you have any doubts.

[jedigeiss]

Honestly and with all respect, I do not really get what the problem here is.
Suggestions are ideas on how a project could improve.
Instead of the expression technical aspects I would at least like to have the option to receive ideas about functional aspects of a project.
These are in the end the real deal, a good idea is what makes the world go round and as far as I can see those are not bad ones are they ?
Kind regards
Jan

[syedumair]

Hey @jedigeiss
Thank you for dropping by
With all respect we, the moderators have to follow the rules and it is clearly mentioned that features must have have technical background.

However if the PO's want to receive suggestions on the functionalities of the project, we are bound to change our decisions.
I would really appreciate the project owners if they take a few minutes to score a contribution on their respective projects as it will ease the moderation process.

Anyways, thank you for commenting.
I will ask my superior to accept this contribution.

[obvious]

I will ask my superior to accept this contribution.

So, is there any response on this?

[syedumair]

No, your contribution cannot be approved.
Current rules do not allow us to accept such contributions.

[obvious]

So one day its this and on the other day its that....

well, thx for your time....